The Ministry Dilemma: Balancing Maintenance and Growth
Every thriving ministry needs both maintenance and growth—the challenge is knowing which season you're in and when to shift.
In ministry leadership, there's a natural tension that every leader must navigate. It's not about choosing between right and wrong approaches—it's about discerning between what's needed now and what's needed next. As church leaders, we need to find a balance between maintenance mode and growth mode.
Many of us find ourselves bouncing between urgent issues, solving problems as they arise and trying to keep ministry systems running smoothly. This reactive state can become our default, especially when pressures mount. We respond by prioritizing stability and appointing reliable "maintainers" to ministry roles—dedicated people who excel at preserving what exists.
Here's the key insight: Both maintenance and growth serve crucial purposes in different seasons. The challenge isn't eliminating one for the other—it's recognizing which mode your ministry currently operates in and whether that aligns with your current needs and calling.
Understanding the Maintenance Mindset
Maintenance mode is fundamentally about preservation. It says, "Let's keep things from falling apart." Moses demonstrated this when establishing judges to handle disputes in Exodus 18—he needed structure to sustain what God had started. In many seasons, this stabilizing function is exactly what ministry requires.
Good maintainers bring incredible value, ensuring consistency, protecting established systems, and providing reliability when it’s needed most. They excel at solving problems and creating stability, qualities essential for certain ministry roles and seasons.
However, long-term maintenance without growth carries an inherent limitation: it preserves but doesn't advance. When maintenance becomes the permanent strategy rather than a seasonal necessity, churches often mistake activity for advancement. Staff meetings revolve around calendars and complaints rather than vision and strategy. Vision gradually leaks, culture steadily drifts, and ministry impact plateaus.
Cultivating a Growth Mindset
Growth mode, by contrast, is driven by mission. It asks essential questions: "Where is God leading us? Who must we become to get there? What needs to change?"
This reflects the early Church in Acts, not merely surviving but multiplying. Growth mode embraces necessary change, fosters innovation, and develops people. It refuses to settle for "good enough" because it operates from the conviction that God is always doing a new thing.
To foster genuine growth, churches need more than efficient systems; they need leaders with vision and conviction. They need builders, not just maintainers, and pioneers, not just preservers.
The Digital Ministry Connection
Today's ministry landscape requires both maintenance and growth mindsets to be applied thoughtfully to your digital presence. Your online platforms aren't just technological tools—they're mission-critical ministry spaces where both stability and innovation matter.
Churches with a maintenance-focused digital strategy tend to treat their website and social media as static digital brochures, reliable but rarely refreshed. They maintain what exists but miss opportunities for deeper engagement. This approach works during some seasons when consistency is the primary need.
Churches with a growth-focused digital mindset see these same platforms as dynamic relationship-building environments. They experiment with new approaches, measure engagement metrics, and continuously refine their digital strategy. They use technology to help people take meaningful steps toward Christ and community.
The most effective ministries know when to stabilize their digital systems (maintenance) and when to push into new digital territories (growth). Neither approach is inherently superior—timing and purpose determine which is needed.
The Firefighting Trap (and Finding Balance)
Here's the core challenge many ministries face: getting stuck in perpetual firefighting mode. When this happens, we chase problems instead of pursuing purpose. In that chaos, we sometimes make desperate decisions about leadership roles, elevate people prematurely, or prioritize immediate peace over long-term progress.
Charlotte Gamble brilliantly illustrates this with her metaphor of "mice," minor distractions that steal focus and sabotage healthy ministry rhythms:
The Mouse Called Reluctance: When you appoint someone who's reluctant, regardless of whether they're a maintainer or grower, you're not raising a leader. You're creating an unsustainable situation. The best maintainers are those who embrace their stabilizing role with conviction, not those who accept it with resignation.
The Mouse Called Immaturity: Roles need to match readiness. Both maintenance and growth require appropriate maturity, just in different ways. A maintainer needs the maturity to handle consistent responsibilities, while a growth-focused leader needs the maturity to navigate change and uncertainty.
The Mouse Called Distraction: Chasing every new idea or copying another church's approach without discernment creates confusion in either mode. Maintainers get pulled from their stabilizing work, while growth-oriented leaders never focus long enough on one direction to see results.
Every ministry needs both maintainers and builders, but they must be in the right roles at the right time for the right reasons.
Recognizing When It's Time to Shift
How do you recognize when your ministry needs to shift from maintenance to growth mode? Watch for these five indicators:
Vision feels static or routine. When conversations center more on preserving the past than pursuing possibilities, it may be time to reawaken your growth muscles.
Team energy is steady but not sparked. Maintainers provide reliable consistency, but when your ministry needs fresh momentum, growth-oriented leaders bring catalytic energy.
You're solving identical problems repeatedly. Maintenance mode keeps systems running, but it sometimes doesn't address the root causes. Growth mode breaks stagnant cycles by reimagining approaches.
The culture feels comfortable but unchallenged. When no one questions processes or pursues excellence, comfort may be crowding out your church’s potential.
Transformation stories have become scarce. Beyond attendance metrics, when testimonies of life change become infrequent, your ministry may need growth-oriented leadership to revitalize its impact.
Remember, shifting between maintenance and growth isn't about declaring one approach "right" and the other "wrong." It's about aligning your leadership approach with your current season and calling. Some ministries need stability and consistent systems right now. Others need fresh vision and innovative approaches. The key is honest discernment about which season you're in.
Moving Forward: Creating Healthy Rhythms
Creating a thriving ministry requires wisdom to know when to maintain and when to grow. Effective ministry leaders develop these healthy rhythms:
Strategic maintenance seasons: Intentionally schedule time to focus on improving systems, documenting processes, and ensuring that things remain sustainable. Seasons of ministry change, and our teams change; these aren't "settling" seasons—they're strategic investments that shore up the foundation of your church.
Planned growth initiatives: Rather than throwing spaghetti at the wall type innovation, designate specific seasons to pursue new approaches, launch fresh ministries, or reimagine existing programs.
Team composition assessment: Regularly evaluate whether your team balance reflects your current ministry season. Maintenance-heavy seasons need reliable stabilizers. Growth seasons require visionary activators.
Honest culture conversations: Create safe spaces where team members can discuss whether your current approach aligns with your ministry's needs and calling. Is maintenance becoming avoidance? Is growth becoming chaotic?
The most effective ministries aren't permanently fixed in either maintenance or growth mode—they develop a dynamic rhythm between the two. They recognize that both stability and innovation serve the mission when deployed at the right time.
Conclusion: Finding Your Ministry Rhythm
Both maintenance and growth serve vital purposes in ministry—the key is discerning what you need at this moment. Maintenance keeps ministry systems functioning reliably. It provides stability during transition, consistency during uncertainty, and sustainability during expansion. Good maintainers are incredible gifts to any ministry team. Growth pushes ministry forward into new territory. It catalyzes fresh vision, develops new leaders, and reaches new people. Growth-oriented leaders help ministries avoid stagnation and fulfill their kingdom potential.
Church leader, your calling isn't to permanently choose one mode over the other. It's to discern your current season and lead accordingly wisely. Sometimes, that means strengthening systems and stabilizing ministries. At other times, it means challenging one's comfort zone and pursuing a bold vision. Don't let the daily demands determine your leadership approach. Don't let "mice" distract you from intentional discernment. Instead, regularly step back, assess your ministry season, and align your leadership accordingly.
The most impactful ministries develop a dynamic rhythm—they know when to maintain and when to grow. They appreciate maintainers for their stability and builders for their vision. And they ensure the right people are serving in the right roles during the right seasons. Your ministry needs both maintenance and growth. The question is: which does it need right now?
Michael Visser
Co-founder, Threefold Solutions
P.S. We assist with coaching, training, strategy, and support.
#1: Need help with implementation? Reach out to us at info@threefold.solutions or contact us here.
#2: Want to learn more? Subscribe to our YouTube Channel.
#3: Stay in the know with our weekly newsletter, The Fold. Each week we discuss topics on church growth and management, volunteer and staff engagement, leadership development, and more.
